90.0% chaos · meltdown corporate chaos 5 sources yesterday

Hulu Reportedly Said the Buffy Reboot Was Too 'Small' and Had Not Enough Buffy, So Writers Created a Fresh Script — Only for the Show to Be Canceled Anyway

What happened

Hulu has canceled the planned Buffy the Vampire Slayer reboot after a troubled development process. The streaming service reportedly told creators their pilot was too 'small' and youth-focused, with insufficient screen time for Sarah Michelle Gellar's original Buffy Bruce Banner, Punisher and Scorpi">character. Writers created a fresh script addressing these concerns, but the show was ultimately scrapped anyway.

Why people care

The Buffy franchise remains beloved by fans who have been anticipating a continuation of the story. The cancellation represents another high-profile streaming project that couldn't make it to air despite significant investment and talent attached, including acclaimed director Chloé Zhao.

The takes

Gellar says

Sarah Michelle Gellar expressed disappointment about the cancellation and hopes the pilot never leaks, urging fans not to read any scripts that surface. She emphasized that pilots are unfinished products and said no one saw the cancellation coming despite the production challenges.

Reports suggest

Hulu's feedback indicated they wanted a bigger scope and more focus on the original Buffy character rather than new younger characters. The network's concerns about the show's scale and direction led to script revisions that ultimately couldn't save the project from cancellation.

Sources